What Is It? What Is Its Value?

Work. We all know it. For most of us, it’s the single largest ingredient of our adult lives. The fundamental definition of work is rooted not just in philosophy or economics, but in biology itself. Work is species defining – think of the ant colony. The colony’s very existence depends upon what looks to us humans as organized, systematic work over its entire lifespan. Survival depends upon work. In higher mammals, work differentiates some members of the species from others. There are both social (the ant colony) and individual (family, reproduction) work profiles for any of these higher-level species. Their work divides them into at least three classes. The most primitive class are the predators. They dominate, fight, destroy, even eat, their competitors. The next higher class are the cultivators: think agriculture, gardening — essentially human occupations. But on top of the pecking order, we find the enforcers. Their power is supreme – they essentially dictate the conditions for the work of the two lower classes. They target deviants rather than competitors. If some members of the species (or society) are deemed to be either threats to the entire body, or even non-contributors, they are exterminated.
So work, as we have come to accept it, can be characterized as some combination of predation, cultivation, and exertion of social force. As individual members of the human species, we probably engage in all three activities throughout our lives. But that separation into three distinct classes does not really describe modern liberal societies, at least not in the same way it did in past centuries, where mobility was constricted between classes, and one’s life work fell neatly into one group or the other. Our lifetimes of social interaction today encompass all three types of work, combined in a complex network of outcomes based upon what we call “productivity” and controlled by something called “feedback.” And the test of success for our species relies on measurements of things like reproduction (generativity) and flourishing (care giving and growth).
The science of economics has also contributed to our understanding of work. Labor depends upon wages, making it easy to value. Chattel slavery was once an important component of economic systems but is no longer. Fundamental to economics is the measurement of value, usually monetary, always identified as some kind of capital. Capital accumulation means building stuff. Distribution of capital is another matter. So, work is a building process. We build stuff for ourselves and for others. Satisfaction comes from building. But it also comes from fixing stuff. Presumably, the market determines a monetary value for both building and fixing. But we may have other measures deep inside ourselves – non-monetary rewards. Economics concerns itself with assessing the value of capital, but also the activity humans know as gambling. Risk taking is as much a quintessential human endeavor as cultivation via agriculture. We are all subject to the ultimate authority of nature and mathematics in our risk-taking — the enforcers in the game of probabilities. But, since it is primarily a game, I hesitate to call risk-taking work. It seems to be more for pleasure; I have always considered an economic system based upon gambling to be a kind of narcissistic indulgence – not a description of reality.
My work may differ from your work. All I can do is observe, analyze, describe. I suspect we both share some common experiences, though. I sense creativity in either building something new or enhancing something by fixing it. I do these things from time to time and generally “know it when I see it.” I sometimes seek an audience for my creative endeavors, relying on communication skills to locate that audience. Writing for Medium or Warp & Woof is an obvious attempt to do that. Beyond writing, I hope I’ve been at least somewhat successful during my life using my communication skills for sharing knowledge and ultimately helping others. Sharing knowledge involves determining what constitutes learning, then what contributes to insight. Even if your work is more concrete, less philosophical, I bet you still spend some time seeking an audience and wondering if you’ve found it. We do like to say we “work hard” – using work as an excuse rather than an objective. I think the measure of how hard you work should be related to how you feel when a task is completed, rather than how much time you spent completing it. Will life be better or worse tomorrow from your work? Do you even know when the task is complete? Let’s avoid the virtue trap of assuming that only through our work will the world will be better tomorrow – making “indolence” a sin. We all are allowed to define our own work.
So, what makes an activity “work”? It seems that certainly energy must be expended in an activity for it to count as work – either mental or physical energy, or both. There must be some problem solving involved. Problem solving requires a definition of the problem to be solved, and a plan (or habit) to solve it. Past experience, or that mysterious entity “knowledge,” will be the basic tools for solving the problem. Whatever measurement of benefit we apply can be seen as our profit from the endeavor. That profit may be measured quantitatively (as economists do) or emotionally – by that feeling you get. If you can’t imagine it being better, when it all comes together, your profit has been sufficient for your repetition of that activity.
Work relies on both function and form. As described above, function is critical for defining a task as work – it must have purpose, making life somehow better when the task is complete. But form is also fundamental to all the activities we call work. Repetition of a task is its own reward in many cases – contributing to our sense of profit from the activity. This probably has to do with mortality, with longevity. Habits generally feel good. If you accept an emphasis on form, the next question is: does value increase with age? Since new experiences become rarer as we age, past experiences – “nostalgia” – tend to loom larger for our emotional well-being. We take pride in our past accomplishments, sighing as we look back at our lives: “Yes, it was good!” AUTHOR’S NOTE: I’m now in the position of making excuses for my lack of posting anything in two months or more – a long hiatus from writing for me. But the absence of new Warp & Woof posts is because of the paucity of new experiences (like travel — more on that later).
— William Sundwick